Central Bank Action Supports Credit Crisis View

The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. We have coined this term to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government, which involve unprecedented money printing. This is the official blog of the New York Investing meetup.

There was another confirmation of an emerging credit crisis yesterday as central banks in various parts of the globe took coordinated action to pump money into the financial system. The banks involved though claimed it was mere coincidence that they all acted at the same time.

Central banks are generally only interested in dealing with their own internal matters. On ocassion though, they act together as they did in October 2008 at the height of the Credit Crisis. Massive stimulus from lower interest rates and quantitative easing finally allowed the markets to put in a bottom six months later.

On Thursday, the People's Bank of China cut its key lending rate by 31 basis points (a basis point in one-hundredth of a percent) to 6%. This was a previous cut less than a month ago. Manufacturing has been declining for months now in China and there are some estimates that GDP will barely be above 7% this quarter. While this would be enviable for any North American or European economy, below 7% growth would feel recessionary in China. Lowering interest rates is not without risk for China since the country also has a massive real estate bubble and this will continue to feed it. 

At the same time that China was cutting rates, the ECB cut its refinancing rate to 0.75% from 1.00%. The banks' deposit rate however was lowered to zero (obviously not much room to maneuver left there). While the ECB has still not fully implemented ZIRP (zero interest rate policy), which Japan and the United States have now maintained for years, it is so close that the difference is irrelevant for all practical purposes.  The Bank of England did not lower its 0.50% benchmark rate, but instead raised the ceiling on its current round of quantitative easing by 50 billion pounds. They've obviously come to the conclusion that once rates have gotten close to zero, money printing is the only way to go.

Absent in any obvious way from yesterday's action was the U.S. Federal Reserve. It already had its monthly meeting at the end of June and announced an extension of Operation Twist (an attempt to drive 10-year yields lower even though they had already hit all-time lows on June 1st). The market bulls were claiming that the Fed would announce a third round of quantitative easing, but they didn't. The Fed is also going to have trouble engaging in more QE in the near future because the U.S. is once again near its debt limit. National debt is now over $15.8 trillion and the debt ceiling is $16.4 trillion. The two will come together at some point this fall. To implement quantitative easing, the Fed has to buy newly issued treasuries. When the debt ceiling is reached, there won't be any. It took months to raise the debt ceiling last time and it is likely to be just as contentious an issue this time as well.

The current global financial crisis is centered in Europe and nothing has been fixed there. The EU has been trying to keep 10-year bond yields below the critical 6% level in Spain and Italy since last summer. They have utterly failed in the case of Spain. Spanish 10-year governments were over 7% in June (higher than last fall, which was in turn higher than last summer). After being driven down close to 6% twice in the last two weeks, the yield was as high as 7.04% today. Italian 10-years traded at 6.08%. Rates continually above 6% mean that Spain and Italy will need bailouts, but the necessary money will have to be printed. Germany holds the keys to the printing press however and may not let them be used.

Stock markets worldwide have held up remarkably well considering there are serious problems in the financial system and the global economy is weak. Liquidity from central banks is responsible for this. However markets have a tendency to revert to realistic prices and if they aren't allowed to do that gradually, they will do so suddenly.

Disclosure: None

Daryl Montgomery
Author: "Inflation Investing - A Guide for the 2010s"
Organizer, New York Investing meetup
http://investing.meetup.com/21

This posting is editorial opinion. There is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security.

When Stimulus Ceases to be Stimulating

The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. In addition to the term helicopter economics, we have also coined the term, helicopternomics, to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government and to update the old-fashioned term wheelbarrow economics.

Our Video Related to this Blog:

Apparently Pavlov was right - and a better economist than anyone ever imagined. More than 100 years ago he noted that a stimulus has its greatest effect in the beginning and loses it impact if continually applied. Contemporary central bankers have apparently failed to appreciate the significance of this finding and its application to their field.

Early this morning New York time, the Bank of England cut interest rates 1.5%. While this may not be the biggest rate cut ever in nominal terms, it is enormous by any measure. The old rate was 4.75 and the new one is 3.25. Before the credit crisis began last year, a rate cut of this magnitude would have been enough to rally the market 10%, 15% or maybe even 20% in as little as a few days. However, as the credit crisis has proceeded, central banks rate cuts have lost their efficacy. The rallies that have resulted have become smaller and briefer. Today the FTSE 100 closed down 5.7%. Instead of the expected big rally, the London market crashed.

The Bank of England's grand rate cut gesture was a follow-up to the U.S. Fed's 50 basis point pre-election rate cut last week. While the Fed's cut helped prop up the American stock market into the voting, it could have done even more and there were rumors that it was considering 75 or even a 100 point cut (the remaining 25 or 50 basis point cut will probably be done at the next meeting). The ECB and the Swiss central bank decided to follow this more conservative approach today when they both cut 50 basis points also. Euro zone rates are now at 3.25%, above Britain's new 3.00% and well above the 1.00% in U.S. Counterintuitively, the trade weighted dollar rallied. This pattern has been seen since late July when funds have been flowing from high interest rate currencies to low interest rate currencies - something which seems to defy all logic.

Bourses on the continent suffered even more today than the British market, since they only had a big rate cut, instead of a truly huge rate cut to support stock prices. The German DAX was down 6.8% and the CAC-40 dropped 6.4%. The U.S. markets started selling as soon as they opened and hit a temporary bottom around 1:30, when the Dow was down more than 400 points and Nasdaq down over 70. Oil prices was hit even worse than stocks, with light sweet crude falling to $60.16 at one point. Don't be surprised if oil falls even further to 50 or even 40 in the future, although this may take awhile. In the shorter term, current levels are likely to be broken for stocks.

NEXT: Employment Losses Revealed After the Election

Daryl Montgomery
Organizer, New York Investing meetup
http://investing.meetup.com/21

This posting is editorial opinion. Like all other postings for this blog, there is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security.

The New Crash Monday Phenomenon

The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. In addition to the term helicopter economics, we have also coined the term, helicopternomics, to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government and to update the old-fashioned term wheelbarrow economics.

Our Videos Related to this Blog:

Three weeks ago, Monday was an ugly day in the U.S stock markets. The Dow was down around 500 points. The drop two weeks later on Monday was even worse, the Dow was down 778 points. At the bottom yesterday, another Monday, the Dow was off 822 points (it closed down only 370 or 3.6% however). The other indices were hit even harder. The bank failures, bailouts, and sometimes lack of bailouts that are taking place over the weekend are the cause of these Monday downward spirals. When the major bank failures end or the market hits a definitive bottom, Monday will once again be a safe day to be long in the market.

Unlike the previous Monday routes, significant intraday buying came in during the afternoon to lift the stock indices off their lows. It was reported that the shadowy U.S. government operation known as the plunge protection team had met in the morning and just before noon, a number of new Fed money pumping operations were announced (a lot more of the same things that haven't worked in the past). This didn't immediately reassure the market, which kept dropping until approximately 2:45. At the lows, the Dow hit 9503, the S&P 500 1008 and the Nasdaq 1777. The S&P and Nasdaq lows were in areas of strong chart support (mentioned in last Saturday's posting), the Dow's low was not. A strong rally followed and the Dow managed to close at 9955 (the first close below 10,000 since 2004), the S&P at 1057 and the Nasdaq at 1863. Europe though having closed before the rally period began lost heavily. The Euro Stoxx 600 index was down 7.6% on the day. As usual in times of market crisis, gold rallied closing up $33 and oil tanked closing down $6.07 at 87.81.

While yesterday's market action didn't feel like a definitive bottom, a number of indicators reached levels that have previously signaled bottoms. New Lows reached 1078 toward the close and anything over 1000 is typical of major bottoms. The VIX, a measure of market volatility, hit 58 during the day, it's high during 2002 was only 55 (however, it rose to 150 during the 1987 market meltdown and this could happen again). The TED spread, a measure of perceived credit risk in the economy, which had already blown past it's 1987 highs of around 3.00 in September, reached 3.91. Market breadth, with 15 to 1 declining stocks to advancing stocks on the NYSE was also indicative of a bottom. However, it was even worse last Monday. Volume was high on the Nasdaq, but not outrageously so, and only somewhat above average on the Dow - not signs of a washout. A successful test of yesterdays lows would create some reassurance that the market has indeed bottomed (at least for now).

Crash Mondays seem to always be followed by rally Tuesdays (although today may be an exception). The panicky authorities pull out all the stops to get the market going back up again. The Fed first announced that it's TAF auctions would now be for $150 billion each (they started at $20 billion last December). Funding limits for its other operations were raised as well. Last night Australia lowered rates a full percentage point, jumping the gun on a possible coordinated world-wide central bank interest rate cut. This morning the U.S. Fed announced that it will buy worthless commercial paper on the open market to unclog the credit system. Let me assure you that the stock market will eventually succumb to these manipulations and rise appropriately. Unfortunately, so will the price of everything else. You may have to sell some of those higher priced stocks in the future to pay for your $100 hamburgers.

NEXT: The Third Crash is the Charm - Fed to the Rescue

Daryl Montgomery
Organizer, New York Investing meetup
http://investing.meetup.com/21

This posting is editorial opinion. Like all other postings for this blog, there is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security.

More Collateral Damage from the Fed's First Helicopter Drop

The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. In addition to the term helicopter economics, we have also coined the term, helicopternomics, to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government and to update the old-fashioned term wheelbarrow economics.

The impact of the Fed's September 18, 2007 rate cut was not limited to the panic sell off in the dollar and the incipient bubble in gold, silver, oil, and food commodities. The lower rates that were supposed to help the housing market didn't materialize. By the end of the month, mortgage rates were actually higher than they had been before the Fed's action. Instead of helping the beleaguered housing industry and homeowners , the Fed's rate cut was actually ineffective at best and did nothing to decrease costs for those struggling to deal with ballooning mortgage debt.
Of course, in reality it was the big banks and broker-dealers that were stuck with increasingly worthless securities backed by subprime loans that were the real target of the Fed's beneficence. It would prove to be too little too late however. By October, the first of a series of multi-billion dollar quarterly write offs would start - $5.5 billion for Merrill Lynch, $3.4 billion for UBS, $3.3 billion for Citibank, and $3.1 billion for Deutsche Bank. As bad as these write offs looked at the time, they were not nearly as bad as what was to come.

The Fed cuts also gave the Wall Street Pollyannas ammunition to game up the market, since Fed cuts were traditionally bullish for stocks. The financial media had wall to wall coverage of talking heads urging viewers to buy stocks now because they were at fantastic bargain prices (of course at a real bottom no one appearing in the media urges viewers to buy stocks). Any experienced trader looking at the market rally that ensued knew something was terribly wrong however. While the market had sold off in heavy volume in late July and the first half of August, it rallied on light volume and then hit new highs on even lighter volume. Trends on low volume are usually soon reversed and the September rally would prove to be no exception.

Next: The U.S. Government Goes from Lying with Statistics to Just Lying

Daryl Montgomery
Organizer, New York Investing meetup

For more about us, please see our web site: http://investing.meetup.com/21

The Markets React to Helicopternomics and so does New York Investing

The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. In addition to the term helicopter economics, we have also coined the term, helicopternomics, to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government and to update the old-fashioned term wheelbarrow economics.

The U.S. Federal Reserves 50 basis point rate cut on September 18, 2007 would prove to be a seminal event in U.S. economic history. As is the case for many actions that have potentially disastrous impacts, there was a swift and stupendously negative reaction after the Fed lowered rates. It was clear immediately to almost everyone except the Fed and its Wall Street supplicants that the rate cut decision had been the wrong one.

Starting that day, the trade-weighted dollar (the value of the dollar against the currencies of the Americas largest trading partners) already down 33% from its peak level during the Bush administration, started selling off and looked like it was setting itself up for a potential collapse. On the Monday following the Fed’s move, the U.S. dollar hit the first of a series of all time lows By the end of September, the value of dollar would be down against almost every currency on the planet, including the Philippine peso, the Brazilian real, the Turkish lira and the Botswanan pula. People everywhere were desperate to get rid of their dollars and even preferred to hold currencies from countries that had previously been so monetarily irresponsible that they had experienced hyperinflation.

In the future, people would see this episode as the beginning of the end of the U.S. dollar as the reserve currency for the world. Years of excessive government, consumer and business borrowing and irresponsible U.S. monetary policy were finally turning the dollar into a currency that people wanted to avoid rather than hold. Loss of reserve currency status would be definitive once the world oil producers stopped pricing their wares in dollars. While this was still some time in the future, the inevitability of this outcome had now become a certainty.

The fallout from the Fed's monetary easing was unfortunately not limited to its impact on the U.S. currency. The falling dollar acted as the spark that ignited a rally in the commodity markets. Since most commodities were priced in dollars, everything else being equal, their prices had to go up as the dollar fell. A large basket of commodities tracked by the CRB index rallied over 8% during the month of the Fed rate cut, the biggest such increase since the high-inflation 1970s. It was perhaps even more disturbing that the commodities most sensitive to inflation, gold and oil, had some of the strongest rallies. Only three days after the Fed’s cut, gold hit a 27-year high. Oil hit a series of all time highs breaking through $80 a barrel and then $90 a barrel only weeks later. Most investors were so euphoric at the Fed’s largess to Wall Street, that they failed to notice that the markets were not just saying there was serious inflation on the horizon, they were screaming it.

The seriousness of the damage the Fed was causing and was intending to cause to the U.S. economy motivated the New York Investing meetup to spread it's message beyond its membership. After the September Fed meeting, New York Investing did its first videos on the topics of inflation and the falling dollar (See, "Protecting Yourself From Inflation and the Credit Bubble", http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2d8k75N0qpA). The first of these five videos were done with Alex Paul Morris from MoMoney.TV interviewing organizer Daryl Montgomery. Subsequently, the New York Investing meetup would do its own videos and publish them on You Tube and in a number of other venues.

Next: More Collateral Damage from the Fed's First Helicopter Drop

Daryl Montgomery
Organizer, New York Investing meetup

For more information about the New York Investing meetup, please go to: http://investing.meetup.com/21