The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. We have coined this term to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government, which involve unprecedented money printing. This is the official blog of the New York Investing meetup.
The markets are telling us that the Greek debt crisis, which has supposedly been solved numerous times, is still with us and getting worse. Interest rates on Credit Default Swaps on Greek bonds hit a record 495 basis points on April 21st. While Greece is at the end stage of a sovereign debt problem, the U.S. is at the beginning. Some U.S. corporate bonds have recently had lower interest rates than equivalent treasuries indicating that the market believes those companies are in a better financial position than the U.S. government.
The problems that have arisen in Greece are those that occur when a government borrows too much money relative to its GDP. Eventually the interest payments on the debt become overwhelming and default becomes inevitable. Default can take place in two ways however. It can be a simple failure to make interest payments on bonds or it can result from a major inflation of a currency. With inflation borrowers get the nominal amount of money due them, but that money doesn't have the same purchasing power. Since Greece is part of a currency union and can't print its own money, it can only default by not paying off its bonds. The U.S. on the other hand, can print all the money it wants to so it can only default through inflation.
Up to now Greece has had no problem borrowing money. The problem is that the interest rate it has had to pay in the last several months is so high that it undoes the effect of budget cutting measures taken to get its fiscal house in order. The recent EU and IMF proposed 45 billion euro aid package makes funds available for Greece, but didn't do so in a manner that would lower Greece's interest payments. Unless Greece gets access to large amounts of credit at well below market rates, there is no possibility of it avoiding default. Even if it does, sovereign default in all likelihood will simply be delayed.
So what are the implications for the U.S.? The U.S. is not much more fiscally responsible than Greece is, but is does have the reserve currency of the world and a very big printing press. The U.S. can get away will a lot more than Greece does before an irreversible credit disaster begins. In the last few years, the national debt in the U.S. has been skyrocketing because of the Credit Crisis and the recession that followed. It was estimated in the proposed 2010 federal budget that that the U.S. will owe slightly more than $14 trillion by the end of the fiscal year. Debt service was listed as $164 billion.
Based on the budget figures, the U.S. is paying approximately a 1.2% interest rate on its national debt. Could interest rates get any lower than that? Not likely, especially considering that Federal Reserve has kept short term rates around zero. If interest rates return to a more normal, but still relatively low four or five percent, debt service would rise to around $600 billion, without any further increases in borrowing. U.S. federal debt is continually increasing by large amounts however. If 1970s interest rates return, debt service would eventually rise to around $2.4 trillion for the current debt, which is approximately the total estimated revenue for the federal government in 2010. Long before that happened, money printing would be a major source of revenue needed to run government operations on a day to day basis - and hyperinflation would become unavoidable.
The market has been sending hints lately that it is not happy with the U.S. fiscal situation. Interest rates on corporate bonds from Berkshire Hathaway (BRKB), Proctor and Gamble (PG), Johnson and Johnson (JNJ), Lowe's (L) and Abbot Laboratories (ABT) have been lower than equivalent U.S. treasuries at some point in the last few months. Corporate interest rates should never be lower than government rates, at least in theory, because corporations are supposed to be riskier than a government. The market is telling us that it sees things the other way around. Investors should consider this a long-term warning.
The euro (FXE) of course sold off on the latest developments in Greece, but did not make a new low. The market may therefore have already priced in the full impact, at least for the moment, of debt problems in the eurozone. There are more potential problems there in Portugal, Ireland, Spain and Italy however. Whether the market will continue to see those as more significant than the debt problems in the U.S. is still an unanswered question.
Disclosure: Not relevant.
Daryl Montgomery
Organizer, New York Investing meetup
http://investing.meetup.com/21
This posting is editorial opinion. Like all other postings for this blog, there is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security.
Showing posts with label sovereign debt. Show all posts
Showing posts with label sovereign debt. Show all posts
Wednesday, April 21, 2010
Debt Crisis Back in Greece, U.S.Has Borrowing Problems Too
Labels:
ABT,
BRKB,
budget deficit,
EU,
euro,
euro zone,
fxe,
Greece,
IMF,
JNJ,
L,
meetup,
national debt,
New York Investing,
PG,
Portugal,
sovereign debt,
U.S.
Monday, March 15, 2010
Moody's Sovereign Debt Assurances Should Concern Investors
The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. We have coined this term to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government, which involve unprecedented money printing. This is the official blog of the New York Investing meetup.
According to ratings agency Moody's, credit ratings of the world's four largest Aaa-rated sovereign nations - the U.S., UK, Germany and France - are currently "well positioned despite their stretched finances". The agency does however admit that risks have grown. Based on Moody's past actions, this should give investors little comfort.
In the current Greek debt crisis, Moody's was behind S&P and Fitch in downgrading Greek government debt. As reported in the Wall Street Journal, it took Moody's until December 23rd to make a downgrade of just one notch from A1 to A2. After the elections on October 4th, the Greek government admitted it had lied about its budget deficit and its ratio to GDP would be 12.7%, several times higher than previously reported. Even though the original numbers from the Greek government should have seemed unbelievably rosy, this apparently didn't make the rating's agencies suspicious. Are they likely to be more suspicious of the numbers generated by the politically powerful major countries that get their top ratings?
Prior to the Greek crisis, there was Iceland. According to the Central Bank of Iceland's website, Moody's downgraded Iceland's long-term debt obligations in domestic and foreign currency to A1 (still well within the investment grade range) on October 8, 2008. This was the same day that the Iceland's krona peg to the euro collapsed. Iceland had already nationalized major banks Glitnir and Landsbanki the month before. The Iceland prime minister had stated on October 6th that there had been a real danger of national bankruptcy. That scenario would have justified a rating of C from Moody's, many notches below the October 8th rating.
Investors should also not forget the role of the rating's agencies in giving securitized sub-prime loans top triple A ratings (Aaa in the case of Moody's). Moody's had to downgrade more than 5000 mortgage securities in 2007. The ratings agencies in general blamed mortgage holders that turned out to be 'deadbeats' and not their own practices. They would like us to believe that it was unreasonable for them to have assumed that people with spotty employment, a history of not paying their bills, and who bought houses they couldn't afford would default on their mortgages. If the rating agencies can ignore those problems, investors should ask themselves what problems they are ignoring with U.S., UK, German and French government financing?
How did the rating's agencies do with problem companies? Moody's downgraded Bear Stearns to Baa1 from A2 on March 14th, 2008. The Baa1 rating is an investment grade rating for Moody's (there are five speculative rating's below that level). That downgrade took place on the last day that Bear Stearns' stock traded. Moody's was still maintaining it was an investment quality company. The rating agencies did a little better with Enron, downgrading it to below investment grade four days before it declared bankruptcy. The stock had already lost almost all of its value before the downgrades, so the move was too little too late.
In its current analysis of sovereign finances, Moody's maintains that the major countries will be able to maintain fiscal stability because interest payments are reasonable compared to government revenues. However, government debts are increasing rapidly because of weak economies. If the global economy continues to stay weak, interest payments will go higher , tax receipts lower and debt will continue to pile up. Recovery, on the other hand, will raise interest rates substantially and this could overwhelm tax receipts and create a major debt spiral. The rating agencies are unlikely to consider that the major countries are caught in a lose/lose situation though since they seem to reserve their most speculative ratings for basic logic and common sense.
Disclosure: None
NEXT: The CFTC and Manipulation of the Silver Market
Daryl Montgomery
Organizer, New York Investing meetup
http://investing.meetup.com/21
This posting is editorial opinion. Like all other postings for this blog, there is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security.
According to ratings agency Moody's, credit ratings of the world's four largest Aaa-rated sovereign nations - the U.S., UK, Germany and France - are currently "well positioned despite their stretched finances". The agency does however admit that risks have grown. Based on Moody's past actions, this should give investors little comfort.
In the current Greek debt crisis, Moody's was behind S&P and Fitch in downgrading Greek government debt. As reported in the Wall Street Journal, it took Moody's until December 23rd to make a downgrade of just one notch from A1 to A2. After the elections on October 4th, the Greek government admitted it had lied about its budget deficit and its ratio to GDP would be 12.7%, several times higher than previously reported. Even though the original numbers from the Greek government should have seemed unbelievably rosy, this apparently didn't make the rating's agencies suspicious. Are they likely to be more suspicious of the numbers generated by the politically powerful major countries that get their top ratings?
Prior to the Greek crisis, there was Iceland. According to the Central Bank of Iceland's website, Moody's downgraded Iceland's long-term debt obligations in domestic and foreign currency to A1 (still well within the investment grade range) on October 8, 2008. This was the same day that the Iceland's krona peg to the euro collapsed. Iceland had already nationalized major banks Glitnir and Landsbanki the month before. The Iceland prime minister had stated on October 6th that there had been a real danger of national bankruptcy. That scenario would have justified a rating of C from Moody's, many notches below the October 8th rating.
Investors should also not forget the role of the rating's agencies in giving securitized sub-prime loans top triple A ratings (Aaa in the case of Moody's). Moody's had to downgrade more than 5000 mortgage securities in 2007. The ratings agencies in general blamed mortgage holders that turned out to be 'deadbeats' and not their own practices. They would like us to believe that it was unreasonable for them to have assumed that people with spotty employment, a history of not paying their bills, and who bought houses they couldn't afford would default on their mortgages. If the rating agencies can ignore those problems, investors should ask themselves what problems they are ignoring with U.S., UK, German and French government financing?
How did the rating's agencies do with problem companies? Moody's downgraded Bear Stearns to Baa1 from A2 on March 14th, 2008. The Baa1 rating is an investment grade rating for Moody's (there are five speculative rating's below that level). That downgrade took place on the last day that Bear Stearns' stock traded. Moody's was still maintaining it was an investment quality company. The rating agencies did a little better with Enron, downgrading it to below investment grade four days before it declared bankruptcy. The stock had already lost almost all of its value before the downgrades, so the move was too little too late.
In its current analysis of sovereign finances, Moody's maintains that the major countries will be able to maintain fiscal stability because interest payments are reasonable compared to government revenues. However, government debts are increasing rapidly because of weak economies. If the global economy continues to stay weak, interest payments will go higher , tax receipts lower and debt will continue to pile up. Recovery, on the other hand, will raise interest rates substantially and this could overwhelm tax receipts and create a major debt spiral. The rating agencies are unlikely to consider that the major countries are caught in a lose/lose situation though since they seem to reserve their most speculative ratings for basic logic and common sense.
Disclosure: None
NEXT: The CFTC and Manipulation of the Silver Market
Daryl Montgomery
Organizer, New York Investing meetup
http://investing.meetup.com/21
This posting is editorial opinion. Like all other postings for this blog, there is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security.
Labels:
AAA rating,
Bear Stearns,
canadian. U.S.,
depression.Weimar Germany,
Enron,
Fitch,
France,
Greece,
Iceland,
meetup,
Moody's,
New York Investing,
S and P,
sovereign debt,
UK
Wednesday, September 23, 2009
Fed Decision Today; Dollar, Bonds and Gold
The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. In addition to the term helicopter economics, we have also coined the term, helicopternomics, to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government and to update the old-fashioned term wheelbarrow economics.Our Video Related to this Blog:
The FOMC concludes its two-day meeting today and will issue a statement around 2:00PM New York time. There is no chance the Fed will be tightening its zero interest rate easy money policy, although it may announce some vague longer term liquidity reduction that will take place at some indeterminate future date (like the IMF gold sale that was announced over and over again for more than two years before it actually happened). The Fed knows that without its super low interest rates the economy would go into a tailspin and the stock market would tank. Don't expect the Feds quantitative easing (aka money printing) policy, which is slated to be terminated at the end of October, to be stopped either. Interest rates would skyrocket overnight (treasury bond prices would plummet) and the U.S. wouldn't be able to fund its massive budget deficits. It is not likely there will be an announcement about this today however.
While easy money leads to stock rallies (and higher precious metals prices), it undermines a nations currency. The trade-weighted dollar hit a new yearly low in pre-market trading this morning. The ETF DXY had an ugly gap down yesterday. It was as low as 76.00 on Tuesday (a key support level) and fell to 75.89 in pre-market trading today. Ironically, this was the low one year and one day ago. Perhaps less ironically, I constantly see headlines cross my computer screen about the dollar rallying, but every time I look at the price it has gone down. Can the dollar hold its support in here? There are rumblings from the central banks in a number of countries about supporting the dollar in order to lower the value of their currencies. Look for some possible hints of this from the G20 meeting tomorrow, but don't expect action.
The approximately zero short-term interest rates in the U.S. has led to a carry trade. Traders sell U.S. dollars to buy high yielding currencies like the Australian and New Zealand dollar. This is one reason that Australian and New Zealand dollars have been going up in value. Currencies from countries with upgraded credit also benefit. Brazil just had its sovereign debt rating raised to investment grade. Don't expect the credit rating agencies to ever lower the U.S. sovereign debt rating to junk status though. This should have already been done.
Gold has continued to perform admirably. It has closed above its breakout level of $1003.50 for eight days in a row as of yesterday. The close on Tuesday was $1015.50. Silver closed at $17.16. There can still be some overhang on the precious metals market until the G20 meeting is over. Gold still needs to trade intraday above $1033.90 to finish its breakout. Hopefully soon.
NEXT: Market Sells Off as Dollar Rallies ... As Usual
Daryl Montgomery
Organizer,New York Investing meetup
http://investing.meetup.com/21
This posting is editorial opinion. Like all other postings for this blog, there is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

