Draghi's Sterilization Makes ECB Monetary Policy Impotent

 

The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. We have coined this term to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government, which involve unprecedented money printing. This is the official blog of the New York Investing meetup.

In response to concerns about the inflationary risk of more money printing, European Central Bank President Mario Draghi is going to propose "sterilizing" unlimited purchases of government debt for struggling Eurozone countries. A failed government bond auction in Germany this morning indicates why the plan won't work.

Draghi's newest strategy will focus only on government bonds of three year duration or less. These bonds from the peripheral countries have been snapped up by hedge funds in recent trading days driving their yields down considerably. Draghi will apparently also stress conditionality for the ECB's purchases. Governments must agree to ECB control to get aid and must meet the conditions they agree to in order to continue to have their bond markets supported (Greece has been notorious for violating its promises in this regard).

When central banks sterilize transactions, they pump money into one area of the financial system and remove it from another at the same time. Bloomberg reports that there is an estimated €800 billion of excess liquidity in the eurozone banking system. So, policy makers figure there will be no problem draining an unlimited amount out of the liquidity rich north and transferring it to the cash-strapped south. While this sounds good in theory, reality might be a major stumbling block for this idea to go forward.

While Draghi's plan will only be officially announced tomorrow morning, there was already a failed 10-year bond auction in Germany this morning (only the second time this has happened in recent several years). Germany attempted to sell €5 billion in bunds, but only managed to find buyers for €3.61 billion of its debt. The other more solvent credits of the Eurozone such as Finland, the Netherlands and Denmark are also likely to face this problem in the future. It is simply common sense that this will happen. If the size of the money pie isn't being made larger and some people are getting bigger pieces, someone else has to be getting smaller pieces. Lower interest rates in Spain and Italy are going to mean higher rates in the north.

The voters of the northern Eurozone countries may not be amused when they find out how they are paying for the escalating debt problems in Spain and Italy. Retail sales figure released this morning were lower month over month for the whole Eurozone and manufacturing is continuing its contraction. While Spain is in a full-blown recession, the economies of the northern countries are weakening. Higher interest rates there will not help the situation. It should be an interesting meeting of ECB officials tomorrow. 


Disclosure: Not a Central Banker

Daryl Montgomery
Author: "Inflation Investing - A Guide for the 2010s"
Organizer, New York Investing meetup
http://investing.meetup.com/21

This posting is editorial opinion. There is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security.

If an EU Leader Says It, Don't Believe It

The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. We have coined this term to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government, which involve unprecedented money printing. This is the official blog of the New York Investing meetup.

German leader Angela Merkel revved up the markets on Thursday by saying once again that she and the other EU leaders would do everything possible to save the euro. If traders realized how reliable previous official statements concerning the Eurozone debt crisis have been, markets would have experienced a major selloff.

When the debt crisis first appeared in Greece, Merkel said there would be no bailout and the Greeks would have to solve their own financial problems. ECB President Trichet made it clear that Greece wouldn't receive any special treatment. It wasn't long before they both backtracked on their public statements. On April 11, 2010, a €30 billion bailout was agreed to and this was raised to €45 billion on April 16th. By May 2nd, a total package of  €110 billion had been arranged. This amount was meant to fix Greece's debt problems once and for all. The Washington Post reported that IMF director, Dominique Strauss Kahn, and EU Commissioner Olli Rehn stated, "the plan would lead to a more dynamic  economy that will deliver the growth, jobs, and prosperity that Greece needs in the future". If there were a worst-forecasting-prediction-of-all-time award, both Strauss-Kahn and Rehn could be potential winners.

Not only did the Greek economy not prosper, but it went into a tailspin. Other claims made by the EU proved to be equally absurd as well.  As reported by BBC News, the Greek debt to GDP ratio was supposed to rise from 115% at the time of the bailout to 149% in 2013, when it would then fall. Instead it rose to 165% in 2011. Greece's budget deficit was expected to be down to 3% of GDP (the EU target rate that all members states are obligated to meet). If Greece is lucky, it's deficit will only be 7.3% of GDP this year. It is expected to rise again in 2013 however to 8.4%. So much for that.

Even though Greece missed the EU and IMF's projected targets by a mile, this was only possible because a much bigger bailout took place in 2012. Greece received an additional €130 billion  and got to effectively write off almost 75% of its government debt held by private bondholders (the ECB and IMF were exempt from the write down). Certainly Greece must be better off after €240 billion in bailouts and writing off a big part of its debt, isn't it? Well, no it isn't. Before the first bailout in 2010, Greece had around €300 billion in government debt. Just released figures indicate in now has €303 billion in debt. While debt is no lower, GDP has collapsed, falling over 9% in 2011 alone and currently on target for an over 6% drop this year. Unemployment has skyrocketed with the someone under 25 being more likely not to have a job than to be working. By almost any criteria you wish to chose, the EU, IMF and ECB program has been a complete failure.

Now the EU and its partners are preparing to bailout Spain. Already a €100 billion loan has been committed for Spanish banks. This doesn't include any funds to bailout the government. How bad is the situation in Spain?  Well, Reuters has reported that one of Spain's regional mayor robbed a number of supermarkets last week and distributed the stolen food to the poor. As a member of  a regional parliament, he is immune from prosecution. Government stealing from those that have is of course nothing new, but apparently in Spain there's no attempt to hide it.

It looks like Spain will be asking for a full-fledged bailout soon. The EU will then directly take over its finances.  The total bailout could easily involve a trillion euros or more, unless some EU country stops it after realizing the damage this is going to cause the EU itself, let alone Spain. The long-term implications are likely to be quite ugly for both.

Disclosure: None

Daryl Montgomery
Author: "Inflation Investing - A Guide for the 2010s"
Organizer, New York Investing meetup
http://investing.meetup.com/21

This posting is editorial opinion. There is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security.

The EU May Have Reached Its Bailout Limit

The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. We have coined this term to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government, which involve unprecedented money printing. This is the official blog of the New York Investing meetup.

Today, yields on Spanish 10-year sovereigns tested their yearly high yield of 7.28%, while Italian rates reached 6.16%. This was after funds for the Spanish bank bailout were approved by the EU, although the money won't be going directly to the banks. Earlier in the week, the IMF admitted that  the only solution to Europe's debt woes was to run the printing presses at full speed.

The situation in Spain is ugly and getting worse. Unemployment is almost 25% there and the country is in a recession. The Spanish economy is dependent on public spending and building empty houses that no one buys. The government has recently announced severe spending cuts and higher taxes, both of which will lower future growth. Yet, until today Spain was forecasting GDP growth of 0.2% for next year. It now thinks that GDP will decline by 0.5% in 2013. This is not just an optimistic scenario; it's a Harry Potter fantasy scenario. As is the case with Greece, Spanish economic and financial numbers cannot be trusted. Greece in the early stages of its bailout also produced optimistic projections of how easily and quickly everything would be fixed. Instead, its financial problems escalated out of control.  The same outcome should be expected in Spain.

Bailed-out Bankia is a good example of the how reliable the books are for Spanish banks. Bankia claimed to have earned a €300 million in profits in 2011, but in late May revised that to a €3 billion loss. Now Spain is in line for a €100 billion bailout from the EU, although it has claimed that it needs less. Based on how Bankia did its accounting, Spanish banks are likely to need more, maybe ten times more than that amount. This does not include money for bailing out the bankrupt Spanish government.  

Originally, the EU planned on providing the bank bailout money (structured as a long-term loan) directly  to Spain, who would in turn distribute it internally. When this caused Spain's sovereign debt rating to be downgraded, creating greater fiscal problems for the struggling government, the EU then decided to route the loan directly to the banks. Yesterday, the German parliament refused to go along. They were only willing to approve a loan directly to the Spain itself. It wasn't easy to get even that passed. Twenty-two members of Angela Merkel's coalition voted against it. The leader of the Free-Democrats described the bailout as "a bottomless pit". It doesn't look like German legislators have an appetite for any further bailouts and this is bad news for Spain and Italy as well.  

The IMF has an idea of what to do instead, but its solution could hardly be described as constructive. In a report issued on Wednesday, the organization essentially advised the EU to engage in every type of money printing possible, do a lot of it, and to start doing it immediately. The ECB has already expanded its balance sheet by more than the U.S. has and it hasn't solved the EU's problems so far. Massive money printing as suggested by the IMF would debase the euro significantly. So, in order to save the currency union, the currency it issues must be destroyed. Somehow, there seems to be a logic flaw in this line of reasoning (sort of like, a debt crisis can be solved by incurring more debt).

The bailout news today was disastrous for Spain and Italy. The Spanish IBEX index was down 5.79% dislocations  — a mini-crash and the worst drop in the two years. The Italian market was down 4.4%. The euro hit a new yearly low. The ETF FXE traded down to 120.78. This is below its bottom during the Credit Crisis, but still above the 2010 low made when the debt crisis first appeared. As the situation continues to unravel, more selling should be expected.


Disclosure: None
Daryl Montgomery
Author: "Inflation Investing - A Guide for the 2010s"
Organizer, New York Investing meetup
http://investing.meetup.com/21

This posting is editorial opinion. There is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security.

Spain Bank Rescue — Bailout Déjà Vu

 

The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. We have coined this term to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government, which involve unprecedented money printing. This is the official blog of the New York Investing meetup.

After weeks of Spanish officials denying that Spain needed a bailout, eurozone finance ministers agreed on Saturday to up to $125 billion rescue of Spanish banks. Spain is now the fourth member of the EU to seek assistance since Europe's debt crisis began in late 2009.

The precise amount of the bailout won't be determined until June 21st when two consultants finish their assessment of the capital needs of Spanish banks. The IMF is not involved in providing funds (at least not yet), but will help monitor Spanish banks. The rescue money will be funneled into Spain's "Fund for Orderly Bank Restructuring". Aid will supposedly be directed at the 30% of banks with the greatest exposure to property loans. Bankia, which was recently nationalized, would certainly be at the top of this list. After claiming to be profitable, it had to admit to massive losses.  If Bankia was lying about its numbers, what about other Spanish banks?

Apparently, there are few strings attached to this initial bailout. There are no plans to restructure the Spanish economy to make it functional, nor even to stop Spanish banks from lending to builders of empty houses that no one ever buys or lives in (there is already a huge glut of empty houses in the country left over from the building boom in the mid-2000s, but this hasn't stopped the building of more). With the unemployment rate approaching 25% and a large percentage of Spanish homeowners underwater in their mortgages, neither an easy, nor swift solution to Spain's banking mess is possible.

EU and world leaders praised the latest of their bailouts to the sky. The "everything is great and we've solved the problem" litany should sound familiar. After all, the same thing was heard before, during and after the first Greek bailout, the second Greek bailout, and the various schemes to write
down Greece's debt. Even prior to the first Greek bailout, EU officials stated in March 2010, "We recognize that the Greek authorities have taken ambitious and decisive action which should allow Greece to regain the full confidence of the markets. The consolidation measures taken by Greece are an important contribution to enhancing fiscal sustainability and market confidence". It was all downhill from there. Now, they are optimistic about Spain.

Spanish officials, the ones that claimed over and over again that there was no need for a bailout, are just as optimistic. The Spanish Economy Minister claimed that the requested funds would amply cover any need. He continued by insisting that "this has nothing to do with a rescue". It seems that reality perception needs a bailout in Spain as well.

As usual, the EU has done nothing to solve its escalating monetary crisis except to throw money at it. All the problems that led to the crisis are still there and will continue to drain money from the financial system so one bailout after another will be needed. Greece, Portugal and Ireland all got additional funds after their first bailouts. Spain will need another rescue as well. Italy will be next in line. Lessons from the Greek bailout indicate that at first the stock market is euphoric and then when reality sets in later on, there is a big selloff.


Disclosure: None

Daryl Montgomery
Author: "Inflation Investing - A Guide for the 2010s"
Organizer, New York Investing meetup
http://investing.meetup.com/21

This posting is editorial opinion. There is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security.

More Debt Problems in Europe

 

The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. We have coined this term to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government, which involve unprecedented money printing. This is the official blog of the New York Investing meetup.

While stocks weakened in the U.S. on Thursday because of disappointing economic data, they were down in Europe on the resurfacing of the debt crisis issues.

The head of sovereign ratings at S&P, Moritz Kraemer, speaking at an event at the London School of Economics said that another restructuring of Greek debt is likely, with the bailout partners such as the IMF having to take a hit the next time around. Speaking at the same event, the IMF mission chief to Greece acknowledged it would take at least a decade to fix Greece's finances. His prediction may be optimistic considering the situation in Greece is volatile and its economy is in free fall. 

Greece is of course not the only problem child in the eurozone. Portugal, Ireland, Spain and Italy also need some sort of fix. The Eurozone has attempted to put together a firewall to prevent these countries from collapsing into the same debt crisis that engulfed Greece. There are now plans to extend the ceiling of the rescue aid package to 940 billion euros ($1.25 trillion). This money is used to buy up bonds from the debt-challenged countries in order to keep their interest rates down.

The funds do not solve the underlying problem however — all of these countries are living beyond their means and until they drastically cut their expenses they will require a continual stream of rescue money. German central banker, Jens Weidmann, recognized as such when he stated, “Just like the ‘Tower of Babel,’ the ‘Wall of Money’ will never reach heaven. If we continue to make it higher and higher, we will, in fact, run into more worldly constraints".

The program has been effective in the short term however. Portuguese 10-year bond yields were at 17.39% on January 30th, but were trading at 11.52% on March 29th (still too high for Portugal to remain afloat in the long term). Italian 10-year bonds had a yearly high yield of 7.46%, but traded at 5.29% today and Spanish 10-years were as high as 6.72%, but recently went for 5.47%. The eurozone's goal is to keep these rates below 6% — the level at which Greece got into trouble.

The rescue funds should run out by 2013 and more money will have to be added to the mix. Whether or not this will be the point when additional money is not forthcoming remains to be seen, but there will be such a point. The amount of assistance Ben Bernanke is willing to provide may impact the timing. As reported by Zero Hedge, the  U.S. Fed already holds some European sovereign debt. It could easily buy more. Once again, the end will be the same unless you believe that a debt crisis can be solved by taking on more debt or by printing more and more money. At least some of the more responsible authorities are beginning to admit that this isn't possible.

Disclosure: None

Daryl Montgomery
Author: "Inflation Investing - A Guide for the 2010s"
Organizer, New York Investing meetup
http://investing.meetup.com/21

This posting is editorial opinion. There is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security.

Greece Interrupted — Bond Swap is Not the End

 

The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. We have coined this term to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government, which involve unprecedented money printing. This is the official blog of the New York Investing meetup.

Greece is set to swap its privately-held government bonds today for new ones that will represent a three-quarters loss of the original investment. The deal will allow the country to receive 130 billion euros in funds from its second bailout. Like the money from the first bailout, those funds will eventually run out however.   

The Greek bond swap is the biggest debt writedown in history. Over 85% of  private investors (essentially banks, the deal does not include bonds held by the IMF or ECB) holding 117 billion euros ($234 billion) agreed to the "voluntary" exchange. The CEO of one major European bank described the transaction as about as voluntary as a confession during the Spanish Inquisition. The loss to bondholders is twofold consisting of a reduction in face value of 53.5% and then lower interest payments stretched over a longer period of time. All in all, private bondholders are taking an approximately 74% hit (assuming of course there isn't another writedown or Greece doesn't renounce its debt completely in the future).

Credit rating agency Moody's decided to call a spade a spade and declared Greece to be in default. Moody's line of reasoning in stating the obvious is that it considers a loss greater than 70% to be a "distressed exchange" (that's putting it mildly) and is therefore indicative of a default.  The matter is not merely academic, since there is a significant amount of credit default swaps (bond insurance) outstanding on Greek debt. On Friday, a committee of the International Swaps and Derivatives Association —  the regulatory authority on credit default swaps — ruled that the Greek debt restructuring was a credit event, and this will trigger payouts. How much CDS holders will receive remains to be seen.

Commentary from the EU political leadership on the swap deal was more mixed than after the first Greek bailout (statements back then were upbeat and generally confident that the problem had been solved and Greece was on its way to recovery). French president Sarkozy stated, "Today the problem is solved. A page in the financial crisis is turning." Christine Lagarde, head of the IMF said, "The real risk of a crisis, of an acute crisis, has been, for the moment, removed." German officials were far more cautious however. The French may be correct as long as their words are taken literally. The problem is indeed solved for today. That doesn't mean it is solved for tomorrow.

It is actually highly unlikely that the situation in Greece will be turning around any time soon because of the massive reduction in its debt load from the bond swap. If Greece had a functioning economy, there would be hope. However Greece's economy is heavily dependent on government spending and in exchange for bailout money the IMF and ECB have demanded severe cuts in Greece's budget deficits. Greece is now entering its fifth year of recession, after GDP contracted by 7.5% in 2011. Investment fell by 21% last year after sliding 15% in 2010.  For Greece to continue to operate at all, continued bailout money will be needed. Greece has effectively gone from a welfare state to a state on welfare.

Not surprisingly, some analysts are sounding a note of caution. Predictions are that the financial bleeding in Greece will show up once again later this year. Problems may arise even sooner depending on when the next election takes place (now supposedly in May) and how much power the fringe parties gain. The bond market doesn't seem hopeful either. One year Greek government bond yields were last at 1143%.  Such yields represent collapse, not solvency.

Disclosure: None

Daryl Montgomery
Author: "Inflation Investing - A Guide for the 2010s"
Organizer, New York Investing meetup
http://investing.meetup.com/21

This posting is editorial opinion. There is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security.

Greek Deal is Another "Fiscal Solvency in Our Time"

 

The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. We have coined this term to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government, which involve unprecedented money printing. This is the official blog of the New York Investing meetup.

Once again Greece has avoided a messy default and once again its creditors have had to take a greater loss on their loans and once again standards had to be abandoned to make the deal go through. And once again, we're not done yet.

Realistically, Greece is actually undergoing a messy default; it's just doing it in slow motion. When creditors are not fully paid, there is a default. The original default terms for creditors last summer were for a 21% loss for private bondholders (read banks). This percent has been raised more than once and with the latest round of negotiations, it will be above 70% according to Jean Lemierre, who co-headed the talks for the IIF (Institute of International Finance). The ECB and national central banks in the eurozone have agreed to "forgo profits on their holdings" (presumably this means the interest payments on Greek government bonds -- something which also indicates default).The eurozone countries will reduce the interest on Greece's first package of bailout loans to 1.5% over market rates from the previous 2% to 3%. This is the first time the ECB and other eurozone central banks have agreed to take a hit on their own holdings.

What prompted the further concessions to Greece was an attempt to get its 2020 projected debt to GDP ratio down to 120%. Without them, the ratio would have been 129% even under the bailout troika's (EU, ECB and IMF) most optimistic scenario (for the non-political reader, this means the complete fantasy scenario). Projections during the first bailout deal proved too good to be true and it should be presumed that these are as well.

There are still a lot of approvals needed to ensure that the current deal goes forward. If it does, every Greek man , woman and child will have received the equivalent of $29,000 from bailout payments. Greece holds elections in April and support for the anti-bailout parties is increasing. Whether or not it will be enough to derail the bailout deal remains to be seen.

Greek one-year government bond yields reached a high of 682% today according to Bloomberg.  To say that the market is not giving the bailout deal a vote of confidence would be an understatement. Last summer, they were around 40% and have been rising continually since then. While euro-politicians are once again claiming the problem is solved, the market indicates that Greece is imploding.

Disclosure: None

Daryl Montgomery
Author: "Inflation Investing - A Guide for the 2010s"
Organizer, New York Investing meetup
http://investing.meetup.com/21

This posting is editorial opinion. There is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security.

EU Debt Crisis Spreads Worldwide

 

The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. We have coined this term to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government, which involve unprecedented money printing. This is the official blog of the New York Investing meetup.

As the situation in Greece deteriorates further, Moody's announced today that it intended to downgrade 114 European financial institutions and 17 global banks. Hopes that China will buy up   EU sovereign debt to help prop up the faltering eurozone may wind up costing the U.S. more than it does China. 

The hostility between Greece and the EU/IMF/ECB bailout troika is palpable. Nevertheless, there are claims that a deal should be reached by Monday. Whether the severe budget cuts demanded will actually be implemented is another story. Greece's GDP is shrinking 7% this year and additional budget cuts will only make the situation worse. Athens is already riot torn and elections in April (assuming a democratic government still exists) are not likely to produce a government favorable to the bailout terms. The market remains increasingly skeptical of Greece's near-term future with one-year government bond yields reaching 528% today.

While all attention is focused on Greece, the European debt crisis permeates the continent. Banks have lent too much money to not just Greece, but to Portugal, Spain, Italy and Eastern European countries as well. There is a still a hangover of pre-Credit Crisis debt that wasn't resolved in 2008, but merely papered over with newly printed money. Moody's just announced it was planning on downgrading 114 European financial entities including 7 in Germany, 9 in Great Britain, 10 in France and over 20 each in Spain and Italy. Global banks Nomura and Bank of America are in line for a one-notch downgrade, while Barclays, BNP Paribas, Credit Agricole, Deutsche Bank, HSBC Holdings and Goldman Sachs could have their ratings lowered two notches. UBS, Credit Suisse and Morgan Stanley could be reduced three notches.

China with its vast foreign reserve holdings has been considered the potential savior of the eurozone. If this does occur, it won't be only China that is paying however; the U.S. will be sacrificing as well. China has previously announced it wants to diversify its reserve holdings. Since a disproportionate amount of these are in U.S. treasuries, the obvious implication is that it will be funding less U.S. debt as it funds more EU debt. The most recent figures for November 2011 indicate that China decreased its U.S. debt security holdings by almost 3%.

The EU debt crisis is likely to be us for some time to come. The situation with Greece is not stable and at some point it will have to leave the eurozone. Attention will increasingly focus to the other debt-ridden countries and the weak banking system. Just as the crisis spread from Greece throughout Europe, it will then spread from Europe to the rest of the world. We are already seeing this happen.

Disclosure: None

Daryl Montgomery
Author: "Inflation Investing - A Guide for the 2010s"
Organizer, New York Investing meetup
http://investing.meetup.com/21

This posting is editorial opinion. There is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security.

Will Greek Bailout Deal Falter Now or Later?

 

The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. We have coined this term to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government, which involve unprecedented money printing. This is the official blog of the New York Investing meetup.

The Greek bailout deal is once again falling apart. Whether or not it is patched together another time, the end will inevitably be an ugly default.

On Thursday, news sources around the world were trumpeting that the EU and Greece had come to terms that would allow Greece to receive a 130 billion euro bailout payment that would prevent the country from defaulting by March. But late in the day, EU finance ministers made additional demands on Greece. They wanted another 325 million euros in budget cuts, that the Greek parliament pass the cuts and that a written guarantee that the cuts will be still be implemented after the April elections. On one hand these demands are not surprising since the Greeks have been less than honest about their budget numbers in the past. On the other however, they are surprising because this could be the straw that breaks the camel's back.

Greece is in its fifth year of recession and its economy seems to be in an unrelenting downward spiral. This is happening because just like the United States, Japan and a number of other nations, the economy is dependent on government spending made possible by huge budget deficits. Each time Greece has been forced to cut its budget deficit, the economy has shrunk some more. Additional cuts will only cause additional contraction. Although they receive little coverage by the U.S. media, riots have become common place in Greece (there is currently a 48-hour strike). Democracy might itself be threatened there. Greece does have a history of military dictatorship, with a military junta running the country between 1967 and 1974.

Lately, the country is becoming increasingly politically unstable. The far-right LAOS party, which is part of the governing coalition, has refused to support the new terms of the bailout. Its members resigned the coalition today. Even more disturbing, Reuters has reported that the Federation of Greek Police has issued the following statement to Greek officials: "Since you are continuing this destructive policy, we warn you that you cannot make us fight against our brothers. We refuse to stand against our parents, our brothers, our children or any citizen who protests and demands a change of policy. We warn you that as legal representatives of Greek policemen, we will issue arrest warrants for a series of legal violations ... such as blackmail, covertly abolishing or eroding democracy and national sovereignty."

Even if things are patched up once again and the next bailout payment is made, there will still be another one after that and even more to follow.  Greece is like the family that is only one paycheck away from homelessness, except one welfare check away from homelessness would be a more apt analogy. Eventually, something will give and this will have a major impact on the world financial system.

The real crisis in Europe is not Greece in and of itself, it is the stability of the banks in France and Germany that have lent money to Greece (and Italy, Spain and Portugal). These banks are in precarious shape and a Greek default will have similar consequences to Lehman's collapse in the fall of 2008. Expect the central bankers of the world to unleash a tsunami of money-printing liquidity into the system to stabilize it just as they did in 2008. They will be quicker this time around, so the collapse should be briefer. 

Disclosure: None

Daryl Montgomery
Author: "Inflation Investing - A Guide for the 2010s"
Organizer, New York Investing meetup
http://investing.meetup.com/21

This posting is editorial opinion. There is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security.

The EU Has Fallen Into a Liquidity Trap and It Can't Get Up

The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. We have coined this term to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government, which involve unprecedented money printing. This is the official blog of the New York Investing meetup.

While the EU is still reeling from S&P's downgrade of the sovereign debt of nine of its members on January 13th and the latest talks to keep Greece afloat have hit a wall, there is an even bigger problem with the effectiveness of its stimulus programs -- the money is just not finding its way into the economy.

Global markets were jubilant in December when the ECB (European Central Bank) pumped 490 billion euros of three-year loans into the EU banking system. These funds were used by eurozone banks to buy high-risk government debt from the struggling peripheral countries. This indeed caused a temporary decline in interest rates, especially for Spain and Italy. Money from this program and other EU stimulus measures is stuck in the banking system however and it is doing little to keep the EU from sinking into a deep recession. As of Monday January 16th, the ECB had 493 billion euros on overnight deposit -- more than the entire December stimulus package.

Large amounts of funds on deposit at any central bank are an indication of a crisis in the banking system. Before the current EU debt crisis, eurozone banks usually kept only around 100 million euros on deposit at the ECB. Even during the height of the 2008 Credit Crisis, EU banks kept only around 33% of money lent out by the ECB on deposit. The percent now is over 70% (the ECB has lent out 664 billion euros in total) meaning things are in much worse shape in the EU than they were after Lehman Brothers collapsed. When money is trapped in the banking system, the economy suffers and extra stimulus measures don't help to revive it. EU money-printing measures meant to rescue its profligate debt-ridden members aren't likely to help its economy, which in turn will result in a self-feeding cycle of more and more debt (as happened in Japan during the last two decades) or more and more money printing (as has been taking place in the U.S. since the 2008 Credit Crisis). Like the U.S., the EU has run out of borrowing power, so debt without money printing is no longer an option.

Weaker economies mean more downgrades from the ratings agencies can be expected. On Friday, both France and Austria lost their coveted triple A ratings from S&P. They were downgraded a notch as was Malta, Slovakia and Slovenia. Italy, Spain, Portugal and Cyprus were downgraded two notches. Italy is now rated BBB+. The only countries in the eurozone that still have triple A ratings are Germany, the Netherlands, Luxembourg, and Finland. S&P put the later three on negative outlook for a possible future downgrade however. The EFSF bailout fund itself may also be downgraded.

The current debt crisis that is now impacting the entire eurozone started in Greece in late 2009. The problems there have yet to be fixed despite numerous mainstream media reports to the contrary in the last two years. Greece is now on financial life support. Any missed bailout payment from the EU will send it immediately into default. Talks have broken down once again, but as before will once again be resuming shortly. The market has never been convinced that any of the proposed Greek bailouts will work.  On Monday, Greek one-year government bond yields hit a high of 416% and 10-year yields a high of 35%. These rates have continued to rise after each bailout proposal. Greece has to make substantial bond payments this March.

The EU's debt crisis is not getting resolved because it is no more possible to solve a debt crisis with more debt than it is to sober up a drunk by giving him more alcohol. Yet, every mainstream news article has comments from well-placed sources that are hopeful that some resolution will be coming to the EU's problems soon. Rarely is it mentioned they have been hopeful -- and wrong -- for the last two years as the situation has increasingly deteriorated. Nor is it mentioned that the Japanese with similar problems in their financial system have now been hopeful for twenty years that their economy will fix itself. Wishful thinking doesn't fix markets, nor do plans involving spining straw into gold -- no matter what central bankers and their toadies claim.

Disclosure: None

Daryl Montgomery
Author: "Inflation Investing - A Guide for the 2010s"
Organizer, New York Investing meetup
http://investing.meetup.com/21

This posting is editorial opinion. There is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security.

The Risks to the Global Financial System in 2012

The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. We have coined this term to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government, which involve unprecedented money printing. This is the official blog of the New York Investing meetup.   
As 2012 begins, markets are rallying as they did at the beginning of 2011 -- a year when the S&P 500 closed flat after many huge moves up and down. The problems in Europe that rattled markets in 2011 have not been resolved and new problems are or will be emerging in China and Japan. At the very least, investors should expect another rocky ride in the upcoming year.

The debt crisis in the EU is far from over. It is simply being momentarily contained by another short-term solution that will hold things together for a while until the crisis erupts again. The mid-December LTRO (long term purchase operations) announced by the ECB excited the markets as any money-printing scheme would. This new "solution" to the debt crisis is essentially an attempt to handle a problem of too much debt with more debt. Already close-to-insolvent EU banks are able to hold fewer assets for collateral in exchange for cheap funding from the ECB, which can in turn be used to buy questionable sovereign debt from the PIIGS. While this will keep Italy, Spain, Portugal and Ireland financially afloat for a longer period of time, it may collapse troubled EU banks sooner (the real epicenter of the debt crisis). 

Half way across the globe, problems are emerging in China. It is estimated that there are between 10 and 65 million empty housing units in the country that investors have purchased with the hope of selling at higher prices. There are in fact entire "ghost districts" there that are filled with new buildings and no residents. Prices have become so high that by last spring the typical Beijing resident would have to have worked 36 years to pay for an average-priced home. The pressure appears to be coming off though with new home prices dropping 35% in November. Beijing builders still have 22 months of unsold inventory and Shanghai builders 21 months. In the peripheral areas, existing home sales have plummeted -- down 50% year on year in Shenzhen, 57% in Tianjin, and 79% in Changsha. Investors should take note that the Chinese real estate bubble is far worse than the U.S. one that brought the global financial system to its knees at the end of 2008.

Twenty years ago, Japan had a massive real estate bubble and it is possible that prices have finally bottomed there, but that doesn't mean that they are ready to go up. Japan has had two decades of economic stagnation (and is heading toward a third, if it is lucky) because of the collapse of its real estate and stock market bubbles. Massive borrowing by the government has prevented the situation from getting worse. The debt to GDP ratio in Japan is now estimated to be 229% (well above the just over 100% in the U.S.).  More people are leaving the workforce there than entering it and this bodes ill for tax receipts. The aging population is using up its savings instead of adding to them. This is a potentially serious problem because the massive debt the Japanese government has incurred has been funded mostly internally by the savings of the Japanese people. A lot of old debt has to be rolled over in 2012 and additional debt is still being incurred. Where the money will come from is not clear.

None of the problems that could strain the global financial system originated in 2011. They have been building up for years and even decades. The first major blow up was the Credit Crisis in 2008. In every case, that problem was "solved" by more debt and money printing. This approach has of course only postponed the inevitable since taking on more debt only creates a bigger debt problem down the road and you can't create something of value out of thin air by printing money (although you will ultimately create a lot of inflation). The markets have already spent most of 2011 in an unstable state. It looks like continuing and even bigger crises await investors in 2012.
Disclosure: None
Daryl Montgomery
Author: "Inflation Investing - A Guide for the 2010s"
Organizer, New York Investing meetup
http://investing.meetup.com/21

This posting is editorial opinion. There is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security

Gold Breaks Down, Where to Look for a Bottom

 

The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. We have coined this term to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government, which involve unprecedented money printing. This is the official blog of the New York Investing meetup.

Gold fell and closed below its 200-day moving average yesterday, December 14th. This indicates a technical breakdown and the last time this happened was in August 2008. Gold bottomed approximately 30% off its high three months later in November.

Any analysis of an investment's technical state should begin with the big picture, so recent events can be put in context. Gold is in a secular (long-term) bull market which will last until approximately 2020. This means that the greater trend will move prices higher over time. No market moves straight up however. There are always reversals in a secular bull market and these are sometimes steep. The 1987 stock market crash which took the U.S. indices down 40% and some individual stocks down 70% or even 80% took place in a secular bull market that lasted between 1982 and 2000. Stock prices went to new highs after the crash despite many pundits claiming the crash meant a new depression was coming. Anyone who realized stocks were in a secular bull market could easily have predicted stocks would recover.

Even though gold has dropped below its 200-day (40-week) simple moving average, this does not indicate that it is even in a short-term bear market. At the very least the 50-day (10-week) moving average would have to fall below the 200-day to indicate that. Gold will have to trade below it's 200-day for approximately the next two weeks before that would happen. This did indeed occur in 2008, when it could be said that gold experienced a brief cyclical (short-term) bear market.  The 10-week moving average traded below the 40-week for about four months from September 2008 to January 2009. See a four-year weekly chart of the Gold ETF GLD below.

The bearish behavior of gold in latter 2008 was caused by the Credit Crisis. While you have probably heard ad nauseum that gold is a safe haven in a crisis, this does not include credit crises
(which are crises in the financial system when the banking system has difficulty functioning). We just saw that gold went down during the 2008 credit crisis and yet many gold "experts" somehow can't figure out that it should go down during the current 2011 credit crisis coming out of Europe. In our era, gold can drop during a credit crisis because central banks lease gold at low rates to the big banks and hedge funds. These entities are desperate to raise cash, so they sell the gold into the market (they can't sell many of the assets on their books). This depresses the price of gold -- temporarily. But at some point, they have to buy the gold back and return it to the central bank it was leased from. This makes the price of gold rise again. I explained the entire process in the second volume of my book "Inflation Investing", which covers gold, silver and other metals.

Gold has support at the 65-week simple moving average, but this is not the likely bottom in a full-blown credit crisis.  In order to find that, it is necessary to look at a monthly chart. It can be seen from this that the ultimate support would be at the 40-month simple moving average. Currently, this is around 120 for the gold ETF GLD. This possible buy point, which should be considered a worst-case scenario, was discussed in the October meeting of the New York Investing meetup. See the five-year monthly chart for GLD below.



It's important for investors to focus on the big picture and not get carried away with all the distractions of day to day price movements. Markets go up and down. No market goes in one direction. Every time gold drops, commentators come out of the woodwork saying it means the rally is over and deflation is taking place -- neither is true. It is the bigger price movements that have meaning and gold is in a long-term uptrend. In any secular bull market, a large drop is always a golden opportunity to buy. Just wait until there is some evidence that a bottom has been put in.  

Disclosure: None

Daryl Montgomery
Author: "Inflation Investing - A Guide for the 2010s"
Organizer, New York
Investing meetup http://investing.meetup.com/21

This posting is editorial opinion. There is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security.

Gold and Silver Plummet as Dollar Rallies on EU Woes

 

The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. We have coined this term to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government, which involve unprecedented money printing. This is the official blog of the New York Investing meetup.

The euro fell to a yearly low on December 14th as Italian interest rates at auction hit new highs. Collateral damage to the EU crisis is showing up not only in stock prices, but in the precious metals markets as well. 

The euro fell below the psychologically important 1.30 level in European trade and is testing support from last January. If it breaks that support (and it is pretty certain that it will), the 125 level is the next stop and 1.20 after that. The euro can be tracked through the ETF FXE. At the same time the euro is breaking down, the trade-weighted dollar has broken out. The dollar has been stuck at key resistance at 80 since September. It tested  this level both in September and in November. It traded as high as 80.67 in early morning trade. There is still strong resistance just under 82. A break above that will cause the dollar will head toward 88. The dollar can be tracked through the ETF DXY.

As the dollar rises, gold and other commodities fall. Spot gold was as low as $1562 an ounce in early New York trade. Gold plummeted after the New York open and was down as much as $68 an ounce.
Gold can be tracked through the ETF GLD. Gold decisively broke its 200-day moving average (which is very bearish) and this was the first time it has traded below this level since early 2009. The next level of support is the 65-week moving average, which is currently in the high 1400s.

While gold in general should go up during a crisis, this did not happen in the fall of 2008 -- gold was down around 30% at the time. During credit crises -- and the situation in Europe is a second global credit crisis -- it is reasonable for gold to decline. Central banks lease gold cheaply to banks and large hedge funds and they sell it on the market to raise quick cash (I have explained how this is done is some detail in my book "Inflation Investing"). This time around, there is the added danger that the IMF will sell some of its large hoard of gold to raise money for a eurozone bailout.

Gold's companion metal silver is much more volatile than the yellow metal and is influenced by the economy as well as financial market events. Silver traded as low as $28.47down $2.37 after New York trading opened. This was more than a 7% drop. Silver can be tracked through the ETF SLV. It has strong support around $26. If it breaks that, expect it to head toward the $21 level.

The EU debt crisis is not over and is likely to continue for a while longer and possibly for many more months. EU leaders have come up with one "solution" to the crisis after that has failed shortly after it was announced. Look to the markets to see whether or not their future gambits will create some viable end to their problems. So far the markets have made it very clear that the situation in Europe is continuing to deteriorate and it is dangerous to be on the long side of almost any investment except the U.S. dollar. 

Disclosure: None

Daryl Montgomery
Author: "Inflation Investing - A Guide for the 2010s"
Organizer, New York Investing meetup
http://investing.meetup.com/21

This posting is editorial opinion. There is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security.

New EU Plan is Much Ado About Nothing

 

The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. We have coined this term to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government, which involve unprecedented money printing. This is the official blog of the New York Investing meetup.

Once again the EU has come up with a too-little, too-late solution to deal with its very serious debt crises. Proposals for a tighter fiscal union and the small amount of funds committed will only delay the inevitable default.

Treaties only have meaning if their terms are actually followed. The eurozone already has a treaty that created it. That treaty has very clear fiscal benchmarks that all members must follow. The key benchmark concerning a maximum 3% debt to GDP ratio for an annual budget was almost universally ignored by all member states. Greece was only the most extreme example. It finally admitted to lying about its numbers (it was not "caught in the act" by the central EU head office even though the numbers it submitted were too good to be true). Greece originally reported a projected debt to GDP ratio of 2.0% for 2009. After many revisions, it turned out to be 15.4%. It was not punished for its duplicity or major violation of EU accords; instead it has been offered three bailout packages so far.

The new treaty provisions once again state that the eurozone countries need to have a balanced budget and should not violate the 3% debt to GDP limit. This wasn't enforced the first time and there is no reason to believe that it will be enforced the second time either. This time however the new treaty states that there will be automatic consequences, including possible sanctions. I'm sure they all had a good laugh about those possible sanctions. This is a complete and total joke and should be treated as such.

As for the current amount of money proposed to rescue the over indebted EU countries, it is much too inadequate to be more than a temporary stopgap measure (the only thing the Europeans seem capable of doing). The debt problem for the troubled EU countries -- Greece, Ireland, Italy, Portugal, and Spain -- runs into the trillions. How much is on the table now --  €200billion. The EU will loan this amount to the IMF, which will in turn use it to provide the same amount of aid back to the EU.  Not only is this is a paltry sum, it is disturbing they need to engage in a financial shell game as part of their bailout attempts. Even more absurd is that the ESM (European Stability Mechanism), set up to handle the debt crisis, will be capped at €500 billion. What will happen when they run out of this money and there is still a large amount of debt in danger of defaulting?

The problem with debt crises is that the amount needed to handle them is a moving target. It keeps rising and rising with time because interest rates keep rising and this makes borrowing costs continuously more expensive. Greek one-year bond yields are at 353% today. Even with three rescue packages, they continue to climb toward the stars. Immediately after the announcement of each rescue plan, yields dropped significantly for a short period of time, then they went much higher than they had been before. Expect to see this pattern with the other EU debt crisis countries. The EU is very good at getting its problems under control for a few weeks with its band aid measures.  Expect its current efforts to be another short-term success that turns into a long-term failure.


Disclosure: None

Daryl Montgomery
Author: "Inflation Investing - A Guide for the 2010s"
Organizer, New York Investing meetup
http://investing.meetup.com/21

This posting is editorial opinion. There is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security

EU Deal With Greece Falling Apart

 

The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. We have coined this term to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government, which involve unprecedented money printing. This is the official blog of the New York Investing meetup.

The market lost its rose colored glasses today with Greece announcing a political referendum early in 2012 on the recent EU bailout deal. This could lead to the deal falling apart sooner rather than later.  Stocks sold off on the news in Europe and the U.S. while interest rates rose in Greece and other troubled EU countries.

The deal that the EU put together last week to handle its debt ridden members and to help prop up its banks was essentially smoke and mirrors surrounding a house of cards. It had no chance to work in the long run and the best it could accomplish was to buy more time before the inevitable day of reckoning. The 50% haircut on Greek debt, plus $130 billion euros did provide Greece with enough funds to keep going. It did not stabilize the situation enough however to ensure another debt crisis didn't occur within the next few years. Nor was there any reason to believe that Italy, Spain, Portugal and Ireland wouldn't need a similar bailout in the future. The plans for recapitalizing EU banks were likely to create a credit crunch and send the EU into a deep recession before further steps were taken. The centerpiece of all the bailout operations — the EFSF (European Financial Stability Facility) — was based on essentially printed money that was going to be leveraged. This was how the problem of too much debt was going to be solved.

While stock markets worldwide had huge rallies based on the "good" news that came out of the EU last week (traders like hearing about governments printing more money), they were giving back those gains on Tuesday. Both the German DAX and French CAC-40 were down over 4% in late day trading. The euro, which has held up remarkably well during the entire crisis was down over 1%. Big EU banks were getting slammed hard. France's Société Générale (FR:GLE) was down  almost 17%, Credit Agricole (FR:ACA) fell almost 13% and BNP Paribas (FR:BNP) dropped almost 12% .  Deutsche Bank (DB) was down over 6% and Commerzbank (DE:CBK) down over 10%. The U.S. S&P 500 was lower by a comparatively mild 2% in early going.

Bonds reacted more strongly. The yield on the safe haven 10-year U.S. treasury fell over 6% and the yield was barely above 2% in the morning in New York. Yields on trouble country debt in the EU were moving in the opposite direction. Italian 10-year governments traded over 6.25% (above 6% is considered a critical point of potential breakdown). Only buying from the ECB, which also included Spanish government debt, kept yields from soaring much higher. Yields in Greece were even more telling of the market's true opinion of the EU debt deal and its aftermath. Before the deal, yields on one-year Greek governments reached 193%. They had only fallen to 154% (no solvent country pays anywhere close to this amount) before the announcement of the Greek referendum. This yield peaked at 200% today (November 1st).

Panic was caused by the proposed referendum in Greece because polls show that the terms reached with the EU and IMF are highly unpopular with the Greek people. Even though they have gotten an incredibly good deal, the average Greek is focused on the additionaly years of austerity that would be required on Greece's part.  Apparently, neither the Greeks, nor the markets like hearing that there is no free lunch.

Disclosure: None

Daryl Montgomery
Author: "Inflation Investing - A Guide for the 2010s"
Organizer, New York Investing meetup
http://investing.meetup.com/21

This posting is editorial opinion. There is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security.

It's a 50% Default for Greece

 

The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. We have coined this term to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government, which involve unprecedented money printing. This is the official blog of the New York Investing meetup.

EU leaders have agreed to seek a 50% reduction in Greek debt from bondholders. This supersedes the 21% reduction decided on in July that was supposed to resolve Greece's financial problems. Apparently $30 billion will be given to the banks as an inducement for them going along with the plan. The EU and IMF will also give Greece an additional 100 billion euros in bailout aid.

While the announcement was delivered with a sense of finality, the first bailout of Greece in May 2010 was supposed to solve Greece's debt problems and so was the second bailout this July. It has only taken three months since the  "everything is really fixed now" July announcement before a much bigger bailout and debt writedown proved to be needed. Until fairly recently, EU officials have constantly denied that this would be necessary or that Greece would default. Not paying 50% of your bond debt is not only a default, but it's a major default.

EU officials still seemed mathematically confused about the situation in Greece. EU President Van Rompuy claimed that the current deal will reduce Greece's debt to GDP ratio to 120% by 2020. If so, Greece is still likely headed for more trouble. Since it is estimated that Greece's debt to GDP ratio is around 160%, it should fall to 80% if all bondholders took a 50% hit. Perhaps all bondholders will not be taking a reduction after all. Both the IMF and ECB hold large amounts of Greek government debt and have in the past been reluctant to accept any writedown of their investments.

The pre-dawn news for the EFSF (European Financial Stability Fund), which is supposed to receive 440 billion euros, is that it will be leveraged up to a trillion euros. The U.S. has been pressing for two trillion. This money can be spent to bail out all the EU banks hurt by the Greek default, but only if they can't raise additional capital in the open markets. So the debt problem will be solved by incurring additional debt and borrowing against it. If this isn't a financial system ticking time bomb, nothing is.

The unanswered question is what is going with happen to Portugal (the next most likely crisis), Ireland, Spain and Italy. EU officials tried to minimize the situation by saying Greece is a special case. It would have been more accurate to say that its problems were more extreme and urgent. They are not unique.  The other countries are already somewhere on the path to insolvency and this will have to be dealt with in the future. The only question is how soon that future will arrive. 

 Disclosure: None

Daryl Montgomery
Author: "Inflation Investing - A Guide for the 2010s"
Organizer, New York Investing meetup
http://investing.meetup.com/21

This posting is editorial opinion. There is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security.

October Consumer Confidence Well Into Recession Territory

 

The 'Helicopter Economics Investing Guide' is meant to help educate people on how to make profitable investing choices in the current economic environment. We have coined this term to describe the current monetary and fiscal policies of the U.S. government, which involve unprecedented money printing. This is the official blog of the New York Investing meetup.

The October Consumer Confidence number fell to 39.8. It is once again approaching the all-time lows that occurred at the bottom of the Great Recession. The number has never reached the 90 level since 2009, which is the cutoff for a healthy economy. The continually poor levels of consumer confidence  bring into question whether the last recession ever really ended.

While U.S. consumers are gloomy about almost all aspects of the economy, they are most pessimistic about employment prospects. Only 3% of U.S. consumers think that jobs are plentiful. While it is true that this number could have been lower during the 1930s Depression when millions of ordinary Americans went hungry and were homeless, the lowest possible value is only zero. And the current reading could actually be zero since zero lies within the statistical margin of error for the survey. In contrast, those who say jobs are hard to get came in at 47% and that would definitely had been much higher during the 1930s.

The Present Situation Index — how consumers see the state of the economy currently — was a very dismal 26.3 in October. This number has remained at fairly low levels for four years now. What has caused the overall consumer confidence  number to rise has been expectations for a future improvement in the economy. The government and mainstream media has continually told U.S. consumers the economy is getting better and will continue to get better. So, consumers have told the survey takers that don't see things as being in good shape now, but they were hopeful about the future. Consumers are starting to lose hope however. The future expectations number fell from 55.1 in September to 48.7. Apparently, you can only fool the public for so long.

The "don't believe what you see with your own eyes, but believe what the government tells you" efforts are still going strong however. Media reports cited better retail sales and a big stock market rally since early October as indications that the U.S. economic situation is improving. Retail sales may have indeed gone up since they are not adjusted for inflation and higher prices make them look better even if fewer units are being purchased. As for the wild behavior of the stock market, explosive rallies are common in bear markets and not in bull markets. They can also occur at any point because of liquidity injections into the financial system from central bankers in Europe, the UK, and the U.S. as would happen during a banking crisis like the one currently taking place in the EU. They don't last for long however.

No matter how you look at the consumer confidence, the numbers are ugly. They are not just indicating recession, they are shouting recession. Only 11% of Americans think that business conditions are good.  The Present Situations Index has dropped six months in a row. Some of the components are at rock bottom levels. Yet, the government and mainstream media keep reporting that the economy is on track for improved growth in the second half of 2011. How can such diametrically opposed views be reconciled? The simplest way to explain the discrepancy is that someone is lying. Any guesses as to who that might be?


Disclosure: None

Daryl Montgomery
Author: "Inflation Investing - A Guide for the 2010s"
Organizer, New York Investing meetup
http://investing.meetup.com/21

This posting is editorial opinion. There is no intention to endorse the purchase or sale of any security.